5-Second Answer
Get the Simplex+ if budget matters - it's half the price with waterproof, wireless, and great performance. Get the AT Pro if you want Pro Audio features and Garrett's proven reliability.
Garrett AT Pro vs Nokta Simplex+
In-depth comparison with scores, field analysis, and expert verdict
Price difference: $250.99 (Nokta Simplex+ is cheaper)
Head-to-Head Ratings
Our expert scores based on field testing and user data
Who Wins By Use Case?
Find your scenario instantly
Easier to learn, less investment risk
Better ground handling in salt
Same waterproof, way less cost
Pro Audio separates targets better
Don't overspend for casual use
Tools for advanced hunting
The $250.99 Question
The AT Pro costs nearly DOUBLE the Simplex+. That's $300+ difference. The question isn't which is better (AT Pro is), but whether it's $300 better for your needs.
Category-by-Category Analysis
Expert breakdown of each performance area
Depth Performance
Garrett AT Pro WinsAT Pro reaches 1-2 inches deeper consistently. Its 15 kHz frequency and refined coils give it an edge on deep targets.
Target ID Accuracy
Garrett AT Pro WinsPro Audio mode gives proportional audio response - experienced users can identify targets by sound alone. Simplex+ has basic tone ID.
Ground Handling
Garrett AT Pro WinsManual ground balance plus ground balance window give AT Pro more control in difficult soil. Simplex+ auto-balance works but is less precise.
Ease of Use
Nokta Simplex+ WinsSimplex+ is the easiest waterproof detector to use. Three buttons, clear display, turn-on-and-go. AT Pro requires learning curve.
Build Quality
Garrett AT Pro WinsAT Pro is legendary for durability - many are still running after 10+ years. Simplex+ is solid but less proven long-term.
Value for Money
Nokta Simplex+ WinsAt half the price with waterproof, wireless headphones, and rechargeable battery included? Simplex+ value is unmatched.
Full Specification Comparison
| Specification | Garrett AT Pro | Nokta Simplex+ |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $549.99 | $299.00 |
| Rating | 4.6★ | 4.5★ |
| Reviews | 804 | 227 |
| Operating Frequency | 15 kHz | 12 kHz |
| Weight | 3.03 lbs (1.4 kg) | 2.87 lbs (1.3 kg) |
| Length | 42" to 51" adjustable | 44" to 53" adjustable |
| Coil | 8.5" x 11" DD PROformance | 11" x 7" DD |
| Max Depth | 9-10" (coin), 14"+ (larger) | 10-12" (coin) |
| Waterproof | Full submersion to 10 ft | IP68 to 3 meters (10 ft) |
| Search Modes | 6 (Pro, Custom, Coins, Zero, Relics, High Trash) | 4 |
| Discrimination | 40 segments | 25 segments |
| Ground Balance | Manual with auto window | Auto + Manual |
| Power | 4 AA batteries | Rechargeable Li-ion |
| Battery Life | 10-15 hours | 12 hours |
| Audio | Speaker + MS-2 headphones included | Wireless + wired |
| Warranty | 2 years | 2 years |
| Made In | USA | Turkey |
| frequency | — | 7 KHz |
| weight | 1.37 Kilograms | 3 pounds |
| batteryLife | — | — |
| ipRating | — | IP65 |
| coilSize | — | 11 Inches |
| dimensions | 11L x 5W x 22H | 52L x 25W x 52H |
| material | Aluminum | Carbon Fiber |
| powerSource | Air Powered | Battery Powered |
| model | — | 11000625 |
Pros & Cons Comparison
Pros
- Fully waterproof - hunt in rain, streams, and beaches
- 15 kHz frequency great for coins and jewelry
- Fast recovery speed in trashy areas
- Pro Audio modes for experienced hunters
Cons
- Steeper learning curve than ACE series
- Heavier than entry-level models
- Battery life shorter than ACE models
Pros
- Fully waterproof at entry-level price
- Built-in rechargeable battery
- Wireless headphone compatible
- Free firmware updates
Cons
- Single frequency only (12 kHz)
- Limited modes compared to Legend
- Control box heavier than some
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Garrett AT Pro vs Nokta Simplex+
Upgrade Path
When you're ready for the next level
From Garrett AT Pro:
Garrett AT Max ($779) for wireless audio, or Garrett Apex ($549) for Multi-Flex
From Nokta Simplex+:
Nokta Legend ($599) for multi-frequency, or Minelab Vanquish 540 ($399) for Multi-IQ
This is the budget vs. performance debate in metal detecting. The AT Pro is objectively better - more depth, better discrimination, Pro Audio features that experienced hunters love. But the Simplex+ delivers 80% of that performance at 50% of the price, with easier operation and included wireless headphones. If you're new to the hobby or hunt occasionally, the Simplex+ is the smarter buy. If you're committed to the hobby and want tools that grow with your skills, invest in the AT Pro.
More Comparisons
Garrett ACE 400 vs Minelab Vanquish 440
Get the ACE 400 if you want adjustable frequency and Iron Audio. Get the Vanquish 440 if you want Multi-IQ technology for all-terrain versatility.
CompareMinelab Equinox 800 vs Equinox 900
Get the Equinox 800 - it's $300 cheaper with 95% of the performance. Only get the 900 if you NEED the extra depth or plan to dive below 10 feet.
CompareNokta Legend vs Minelab Equinox 800
Get the Nokta Legend to save $200+ while getting 90% of the Equinox experience. Get the Equinox 800 if you want the proven industry standard with larger accessory ecosystem.
CompareGarrett ACE 300 vs ACE 400
Get the ACE 400 if you can afford the extra $100 - Iron Audio and adjustable frequency are worth it. Get the ACE 300 if you're on a tight budget and want proven performance.
CompareGarrett ACE 300 vs Nokta Simplex+
Get the Simplex+ - it's waterproof, has wireless audio, rechargeable battery, and similar price. The only reason for ACE 300 is if you specifically want Garrett brand loyalty.
CompareMinelab Vanquish 340 vs 440
Get the Vanquish 440 - the $80 upgrade adds a larger coil and more search modes. Only get the 340 on a strict budget.
Compare